The Pittsburgh Steelers are gearing up for another intriguing free agency period, with the potential signing of a veteran quarterback at the forefront of their strategy. With the legal tampering window opening, the team is poised to make a bold move, and the question on everyone's mind is who they will choose. Here's an in-depth look at the options, with a focus on the veteran quarterbacks, and why some choices are more appealing than others.
The S Tier: An Empty Slot
The S Tier remains empty, as there isn't a top-15 starter expected to be available in free agency. If C.J. Stroud were to become an option, he would undoubtedly be a strong contender. However, the Steelers are likely to look elsewhere, as the S Tier is reserved for the elite of the elite.
A Tier: Murray, Richardson, and Willis
Kyler Murray: Murray's improvisational skills are impressive, but his accuracy in the pocket and rhythm are areas of concern. However, his mobile upside and affordable price tag make him an attractive option. Murray's potential value as a vet minimum signing is a significant draw.
Anthony Richardson: Richardson's physical attributes are impressive, with his size and arm strength. However, his low completion percentage and small sample size make him a risky choice. The Steelers would need to trade for him, and his potential contract demands are a factor to consider.
See AlsoVikings Legends: Adam Thielen & C.J. Ham Sign Retirement Deals | NFL Undrafted to Pro BowlKyler Murray to Vikings: Shocking QB Move! Will He Replace J.J. McCarthy?49ers Draft Strategy: Analyzing the Latest Mock Drafts and Potential PicksShould the Seattle Seahawks Draft a Running Back in the 1st Round? Expert AnalysisMalik Willis: Willis has shown sound decision-making and has a high completion rate. His mobility and potential for growth make him a viable option, despite his smaller sample size.
B Tier: Jones and Smith
Mac Jones: Jones had a solid season, but his lack of exceptional skills and athleticism might not excite the Steelers. His performance with players like Kendrick Bourne and Jake Tonges could be a factor in their decision.
Geno Smith: Smith's performance in Seattle from 2022-2024 was impressive, but his 2025 season with the Raiders was a disaster. A short-term deal could be worth considering if he can rekindle his previous form.
C Tier: Aaron Rodgers
Rodgers is a tier unto himself. While his return to the Steelers might not be exciting, it's a move that could be justified. The Steelers' recent lack of motivation and stagnation could be a reason to bring back Rodgers, despite his age and potential decline.
D Tier: McKee and Flacco
Tanner McKee: McKee's potential is there, but his age and lack of significant preseason success make him a risky choice. The Steelers might consider him as a backup option.
Joe Flacco: Flacco's age and uninspiring performances make him a less appealing choice. However, his ability to provide a few standout games could be a factor in their decision.
F Tier: The Uninspiring Group
Tua Tagovailoa: Tagovailoa's struggles in cold weather and overall poor performance make him a poor choice. His 3-11 record in colder climates is a significant red flag for the Steelers.
Jimmy Garoppolo, Andy Dalton, Carson Wentz, Jacoby Brissett, Tyrod Taylor: These quarterbacks have not been legitimate starters for a long time and would not bring excitement. Their lack of recent success makes them less appealing options.
In conclusion, the Steelers have a challenging decision ahead. While some options are more appealing than others, the team's strategy and the potential impact of each quarterback on the team's future should be carefully considered. The free agency period promises to be an exciting one, and the Steelers' choice will shape their future success.
